Jump to content

Livingston ๐ŸŸกโšซ๏ธ vs Partick Thistle ๐ŸŸก๐Ÿ”ด


jagfox
 Share

Lions or Jags  

18 members have voted

  1. 1. Match Result

    • Home Win
      3
    • Draw ๐Ÿค
      5
    • Away (Jags)
      10

This poll is closed to new votes

  • Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.
  • Poll closed on 10/10/2026 at 01:00 PM

Recommended Posts

6 hours ago, jagfox said:

ย 

Enjoyed the text captions here. When there was uncertainty about a player's name, the name of another random player (not playing in this actual game) with a vaguely similar name was inserted instead. So Lewis Budinauckas began as Louis Longridge before graduating to Kyle Benedictus. Cale Loughrey was Keaghan Jacobs etc.ย 

Edited by partickthedog
Louis, not Louise
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Jaggernaut said:

The non-penalty decision could easily have gone the other way. The ref. must have been sure of himself.

A good, hard-fought victory for the Jags.

I agree that the penalty claim looks a lot stronger from the perspective of the Livingston highlights, ie behind the players involved, I was in the section of the Thistle support nearer to the end to which Livingston were shooting in the second half and therefore had a clear side on view. From there it was obvious that the Livingston player threw himself down. The referee did well to see this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, The Thistle Archive said:

Jags finish the quarter on a decent 2 ppg. Levelling all history to 3-pts-per-win, 2 ppg wins the Scottish second tier title 17.5% of the time...ย ๐Ÿ‘€

Livvy archived โ†’

55586210216_43d52019a0_k.jpg

17.5% isnโ€™t very hopeful. Less than 1 in 5 chance. We will need to do much better next quarter to improve our chances.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Dick Dastardly said:

17.5% isnโ€™t very hopeful. Less than 1 in 5 chance. We will need to do much better next quarter to improve our chances.

Just wondering about the basis used for calculating this 17.5 percentage. For example last season St Johnstone were first with 77 (more than 2 points per game) and we were second with 66 (less than 2 points per game). Would last season have been counted as 2 points per game being enough to win the league or not? Only one team scored more than 2 points per game.ย  You could look at this 2 ways:

  • Even if we had increased our 66 points to 72, we would not have won the league (ie 2 points per game was not enough to win the league); or
  • Even if St Johnstone had reduced from 77 points to 72, they would still have won the league (ie 2 points per game would have been enough to win the league).
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If we continue at the same rate as the first quarter, we would have 72 points at the end of the season. While the League Winners have accumulated more points in some seasons, the second placed side has never reached 72 points in any season I checked - I went back to 2012/13 when runners-up Morton managed 67 points.

I did think the suggested league winning percentage of 17.5% at 2 points a game seemed a bit low.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

More depth and nuance demanded, fair! Looking back, there were only a handful of occasions before league reconstruction when the second tier was won with less than 2 ppg; 1912-13 (Ayr United, 1.807), 1924-25 (Dundee United, 1.842) and 1933-34 (Albion Rovers, 1.911), which is hugely surprising and clearly skews the all-time figure in a modern setting. The tighter/smaller second tier of today is a far more competitive environment than it was back in the day.

Therefore, to get a more relevant comparison, it's better to look to the permanent reduction to a 10 team league in 1994-95 (which was also the first season of 3 pts-per-win). In the current circumstances, 2ppg has been enough for the 2nd tier title 13 times out of 31 i.e. 41.9% of the time:

Untitled.jpg

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, The Thistle Archive said:

More depth and nuance demanded, fair! Looking back, there were only a handful of occasions before league reconstruction when the second tier was won with less than 2 ppg; 1912-13 (Ayr United, 1.807), 1924-25 (Dundee United, 1.842) and 1933-34 (Albion Rovers, 1.911), which is hugely surprising and clearly skews the all-time figure in a modern setting. The tighter/smaller second tier of today is a far more competitive environment than it was back in the day.

Therefore, to get a more relevant comparison, it's better to look to the permanent reduction to a 10 team league in 1994-95 (which was also the first season of 3 pts-per-win). In the current circumstances, 2ppg has been enough for the 2nd tier title 13 times out of 31 i.e. 41.9% of the time:

ย 

ย 

Untitled.jpg

That is very helpful (thank you for taking the time to do this) and also more encouraging!

I suppose that to complete the picture we would have to know how many points the second placed team secured on the occasions when the first placed team was over 2ppg (ie if the first placed team had only scored 72 points (which is the relevant figure in all but the exceptional COVID season), would they still have been first?).

PS Not asking you to do this, especially as I am too lazy to do it myself!ย 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, partickthedog said:

That is very helpful (thank you for taking the time to do this) and also more encouraging!

I suppose that to complete the picture we would have to know how many points the second placed team secured on the occasions when the first placed team was over 2ppg (ie if the first placed team had only scored 72 points (which is the relevant figure in all but the exceptional COVID season), would they still have been first?).

PS Not asking you to do this, especially as I am too lazy to do it myself!ย 

Ah, yes, stats can be twisty little blighters!ย 

  • There are a massive 64 historical instances of a club not winning the second tier title with 2 ppg, but only Clyde (2ppg in 2002-03) have been unlucky in that way since the 1994-95 reconstruction.
  • Airdrie and Arbroath each missed out 5 times with a 2ppg ratio.
  • In 1938-1939 & 1971-1972, the TOP FOUR all had a 2ppg ratio.
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, Auld Jag said:

Great work as usual @The Thistle Archive.

Seconded.ย 

No doubt by saying this I will be condemning us to follow in the footsteps of Clyde 2002-2003, but I would be hopeful that 72 points would be enough to win the league and be promoted. With the possible exceptions of Queen's Park and Morton (who are still no pushovers) there is a fair squad of reasonably matched teams who will take points off each other. I would be surprised if 2 teams were to achieve such dominance as to be able to average more than 2ppg over the entire season.

The mention of 2002-2003 has stirred my memories. We were of course delighted at the time that the super plus 2ppg Inverness Caledonian Thistle pipped the plus 2ppg Clyde. It would have been galling for our local rivals to replace Thistle in the Premier League. And of course Inverness could not be promoted as their ground did not comply with the criteria which we had worked so hard at pace and paid so much to fulfil a couple of seasons before. We know how that turned out!?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, partickthedog said:

Seconded.ย 

No doubt by saying this I will be condemning us to follow in the footsteps of Clyde 2002-2003, but I would be hopeful that 72 points would be enough to win the league and be promoted. With the possible exceptions of Queen's Park and Morton (who are still no pushovers) there is a fair squad of reasonably matched teams who will take points off each other. I would be surprised if 2 teams were to achieve such dominance as to be able to average more than 2ppg over the entire season.

The mention of 2002-2003 has stirred my memories. We were of course delighted at the time that the super plus 2ppg Inverness Caledonian Thistle pipped the plus 2ppg Clyde. It would have been galling for our local rivals to replace Thistle in the Premier League. And of course Inverness could not be promoted as their ground did not comply with the criteria which we had worked so hard at pace and paid so much to fulfil a couple of seasons before. We know how that turned out!?

I was thinking the same, but did we not get relegated at the end of 2003/4 season?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, jaggy said:

I was thinking the same, but did we not get relegated at the end of 2003/4 season?

After 1969-70, when we got relegated for the first time in most people's memory back then, we've been relegated so many times that I've totally forgotten the precise years!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, jaggy said:

I was thinking the same, but did we not get relegated at the end of 2003/4 season?

You are absolutely right! I should have checked more carefully before making the lazy assumption that Clyde could not have been so good and so close to promotion to the Premier League for 2 seasons in a row!

In 2002-2003 Clyde accumulated more than 2ppg but lost out to Falkirkโ€™s outstanding 2.25ppg. However, of course, Falkirk did not gain promotion because their ground did not comply, thus saving Motherwell from relegation.ย 

it was indeed in 2003-2004 that the scenario I remembered above played out. Clyde were leading going into the final part of the season and had arranged to play their next termโ€™s home games at Kilmarnock so that they fulfilled Premier League criteria. Unfortunately for them Inverness overhauled them in the final straight.ย 
ย 

Motherwell conveniently forgot their undeserved reprieve in 2003 and happily and twofacedly voted us down in 2004, even though we were compliant and Inverness were not.

ย 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, partickthedog said:

You are absolutely right! I should have checked more carefully before making the lazy assumption that Clyde could not have been so good and so close to promotion to the Premier League for 2 seasons in a row!

In 2002-2003 Clyde accumulated more than 2ppg but lost out to Falkirkโ€™s outstanding 2.25ppg. However, of course, Falkirk did not gain promotion because their ground did not comply, thus saving Motherwell from relegation.ย 

it was indeed in 2003-2004 that the scenario I remembered above played out. Clyde were leading going into the final part of the season and had arranged to play their next termโ€™s home games at Kilmarnock so that they fulfilled Premier League criteria. Unfortunately for them Inverness overhauled them in the final straight.ย 
ย 

Motherwell conveniently forgot their undeserved reprieve in 2003 and happily and twofacedly voted us down in 2004, even though we were compliant and Inverness were not.

ย 

Not strictly true. You're forgetting about the "Motherwell Rule". If the Bairns ground did indeed comply the SPL would've found some way of keeping Motherwell in the top flight.ย ๐Ÿ™‚

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, partickthedog said:

No doubt by saying this I will be condemning us to follow in the footsteps of Clyde 2002-2003, but I would be hopeful that 72 points would be enough to win the league and be promoted. With the possible exceptions of Queen's Park and Morton (who are still no pushovers) there is a fair squad of reasonably matched teams who will take points off each other. I would be surprised if 2 teams were to achieve such dominance as to be able to average more than 2ppg over the entire season.

Solid analysis, hopes are rising!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...