Jump to content

Paulo

Members
  • Posts

    1,150
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Paulo

  1. 9 minutes ago, Dick Dastardly said:

    Am I the only one struggling to see the logic in some of these signings. On paper they do look like improvements on a one-to-one level, but I'm not sure how they all fit in.

    McKinnon and Barjonas will make it 4 (5 when Gordon gets back) fighting for 2 places in central midfield, unless we go for 1 up front, but if that was the case then why bring in Rudden and Graham ? Neither of them signed up to sit on the bench.

    Also, whether 4 or 5 in midfield, we have not addressed the problem with width in midfield, where we lack both quantity and quality. That could come from playing 3 at the back and wingbacks, but if that is the case, why bring in O'Conner who is a full back, and not address the issues we have with our only 3 centre backs.

    I know some have suggested a diamond in midfield, but that would result in either playing very narrow on a wide Firhill pitch, or having Banzo/Cole/Barjonas/Gordon filling in the wide areas and taking them away from where they are most effective.

    Good players in principle, but I just don't see a cohesive plan.

    I see it as the exact opposite actually.  Each player (maybe except Barjonas from all I know of him) has been signed to address a particular weakness in our starting 11.  

  2. It's the typically OF attitude.  Hate the other team more than you love your own team.

     

    Club released a statement saying Celtic fans will be refused entry.  I don't much like the club's approach to these games but that's about all they can do when offering tickets for sale online.  Suggesting fan registration at the start of the season, having to go to Firhill for tickets, showing yer Thistle tattoo to get a ticket are all daft ideas when clubs are desperate to attract more punters.  

  3. 7 minutes ago, ARu-Strathbungo said:

    Weather is not an excuse …. for either side, but the smart manager will field a team prepared for what should be utterly sh*t football weather.

    Could play right into our hands, we've shown a real aptitude for playing utterly sh*t football at times this season.

    • Like 1
    • Haha 2
  4. 23 hours ago, dl1971 said:

    I've never believed that players dont try or are *shite* at professional level. Some are simply not good enough for our aspirations at the time ( insert league to suit ). Then again I didn't actually see the game on Saturday otherwise I may be a little more animated! 

    I have two words for you.  Adam Barton.

    • Like 2
  5. 1 hour ago, Lambies Lost Doo said:

    My main concern with fan ownership is - the fans.

    Ideally you have successful and intelligent business people, breaking even, making unemotional decisions and ignoring the illogical emotional rants of football fans.  Colin Weir is one such fan.  We thanked him, we fawned over him, we named a stand for him (which was madness).  Then there was one potential decision he did not like so he used his emotions, pulled funding directly impacting hundreds of kids and adults and shut down all communication.  Like a child.

    Currently the board has a track record in business success.  They are fans.  They have put in £ and time which is £ lost from their personal lives.  Much more than Colin Weir has ever done.  He got lucky in a lottery.  Dealing with the boring detail and avoiding ridiculous PR BS like previous people. 

    Colin Weir has turned into a populist power broker offering up £ like a benevolent saint.  As long as he gets his own way (while taking no responsibility).

    You've said this is your problem with fan ownership, then just detailed the potential danger in ownership by a single entity.

  6. I think we looked more organised in the first half, but last night seemed to show up that we're incredibly weak in a few positions.  I think we have probably 6 or 7 of a first 11 who are capable, but they can't make up for the likes of Gordon, Mansell and Williamson.  

  7. 5 minutes ago, Barney Rubble said:

    Haven't read the thread, so forgive me if I'm repeating anything.

    Anyone think that Sunday's events may have pushed this decision?

    Would have been nice, as that would show an intention for us as a club going forward, but I think the next statement might reveal more to it.

  8. 13 hours ago, lady-isobel-barnett said:

    I really feel now we are getting more width in the squad that playing 3-5-2 is counter productive. Problem is we don't have defensive quality in the full back area. Williamson & Robson are impressive going forward and both appear to be able to put in very decent quick cross balls. Neither can defend. Penrice is less of a liability as an orthodox full back but still more suited to getting down the flanks. Ideally Saunders could just move across to right back but by most accounts he's not too clever in that role. Perhaps a remedy would be two holding midfielders covering wider than normal but that's verging on the negative side of things, tho' not much different than playing three centrebacks who rarely cross the halfway line. 

    Any views on that? I think we saw some real decent football at times tonight mostly going forward but even against lower league opponents the signs of frailty in defence were clearly evident. 

    I think we lack a true defensive midfielder who knows how to cover the fullbacks when we attack.  

    • Like 1
  9. 5 hours ago, Thistleberight said:

    I'm not saying we'll challenge, just that I'm excited to get the season started.

    It's a good point you make, but there are 3 academy lads in, we've kept a very exciting player in Joe cardle and mansell has potential too. It's not all doom and gloom Paulo. There'll be more signings.

    It'll be interesting, no doubt.  Maybe my excitement is just slow in building....!

     

    5 hours ago, Jag said:

    There are still two months left before the transfer window left. I think if you are comparing the squad to last season, it is only fair to do so at the same time as last season. We are way ahead where we were a year ago.

    Only a couple of weeks until the games start though.  Hindsight is a great thing, but the talk for this season was to get things done early in order to hit the ground running.  I dunno, maybe the whole transfer business is as difficult as Archie made it look the last couple of pre-seasons :D

×
×
  • Create New...