This time last year I would have been happy for him to leave, but I think he's turned things around a bit this season after a poor start. Got some promising youngsters, a decent keeper & a few good players signed for next season. He sent Kinniburgh, Doolan & Boyle out on loan last and all returned better players. Hopefully young Bannigan will be another. He's the 4th best manager we have had in the last 40 years (taking away the obvious Lambie, Auld & McParland) maybe there has been not much competition, but overall I would say his 4 years at Firhill have been reasonably successful.