I wouldn't say Hodge would be a great loss, he might end up being one of these guys that does unexpectedly well at a higher level, but like Cairney I've always thought he was carrying a bit of excess baggage.
After signing Willie K up I thought it was pretty clear we were only going to keep one of Robbo and Archie, Robbo might be the more versatile of the two but I suspect sentiment if nowt else will see Archie get the nod.
Although it might also be to do with coaching- does anyone know if Sid / JM have got the relevant badges yet? I don't think either has much to offer in a playing capacity anymore and as someone said above it might be time for them to dip their toes in the management water, with Archie and maybe Rowser (although his twitter page suggests he's looking outside football for a career when his time's up) moving into the player / coach roles.
I think we'll keep Paddy but Paton will go elsewhere- I'd obviously try and keep them both as they've been our best outfield players this season. I would get rid of Flannigan, flatters to deceive.
MacBeth's an interesting one- I assume he'll be kept on, otherwise I don't see why we would have loaned him to the gypos, but he is injured a lot and has plenty to prove. Don't know too much about the out-of-contract u19s, Burns seems to have fallen behind Fraser and McGrotty in the pecking order though, which doesn't bode well for him as he's older than both of them.