What Doncaster and his supporters seem to be ignoring is that their radical blueprint for improving everything about football in Scotland is simply to turn the clock back 15 years to when we previously had a 10-team top league and a play-off spot for an additional relegation/promotion result. If my memory serves me right, that format was ditched immediately after we got relegated through the play-off (the only team to have done so), because teams were already terrified of dropping out. So it was changed to being only the very weakest (i.e. last) team that went down. Things became worse when they again engineered another two teams for the SPL but retained the one-relegation-place-only rule.
I see that the St Johnstone chairman, his team having spent what, 15 years or so trying to get to the SPL, is now against a bigger league. Having survived for a couple of years in the SPL, he now thinks that his team is safe as one of the elite. This was exactly Yorkston's view a few years ago when he was crying out for the need for relegation but an elitist league. Now, down in the wilderness with the rest of us, the Dunfermline chairman is bleating on about the need for a bigger league! You can be sure that St Johnstone and ICT would think the same way after another couple of seasons in the 2nd tier or worse. These wild swings in chairmen's views really reflect the short-term, gravy train view of those that happen at the time to be in the SPL.
Of course none of this addresses the sheer drudgery of the 4-times-or-more per season format of 10- or 12-team leagues. They say that up to 90% of SPL teams' supporters want bigger leagues. Well, it's about time that those fans took pre-emptive action and announced their intention to boycott matches until they get what they want. It's no good SFL teams doing it, as we have no influence whatsoever on whoever happens to be in the SPL during any season. It needs to come from the likes of St Mirren, Hamilton, Dundee Utd, Killie etc.