Chachi

I didn’t see that game. Based on those I have saw he’s stopped little, flapped at quite a lot and generally left me uninspired. I’d play Sneddon before him, but realistically we need better options in this position.

I’m pretty sure this is what Scott Allison means by becoming a ‘championship’ side, and he, as are you, are correct.

He’s shite.

They all looked disinterested and pedestrian!

We’ve been out played on many occasion in recent times, heavily beaten on many occasions, sickened by many late goals, but that today was horrendous on a new level. A shameful effort, particularly 2nd half. Absolutely zero effort from the players, and a genuine 0/10 rating. We’d have to go back a long way to find such an abject pathetic ‘performance’. For anyone not present, it honestly had to be seen to be believed in its woefulness.

Absolute shambles. 1st half especially. If there was a tactic and game plan being implemented, I'm clueless as to what it was. Maybe it was to look lost, disjointed, uncomfortable in possession, uncomfortable without possession, aimless and passive just to confuse ICT and lull them in to a false sense of security. The starting line up was bizarre at best. We're ****** unless luck goes our way. The ever diminishing amount of light emitting from the floodlights reflects the club in general. Bring your torches to the next Friday night horror show. (that's if you're brave enough to want to watch it)

Whilst he may turn out to be good, as uninspiring signings go this about as uninspiring as it gets.

Good suggestion. I'll be migrating over, as will my brother.

Surely good old fashioned chants of 'Caldwell must go' and 'sack the board' are a good start to get the message across.

One of the most creative players we have. One of the most committed players we have. A fans favourite. All whilst we fling in duds every week who have demonstrated they have little to nothing to offer.

The statement may be mostly correct, but being part of the plans in so much as being as squad player only, and heading for league 1 working for Caldwell versus premiership football for (presumably) the next 18 months or so would be an absolute no brainer for Chris. Who could blame him. I hope he's allowed to flourish there and enjoys it.

If this is true, I'm totally scunnered (as if I wasn't already!) Releasing Erskine whilst playing Storey every week beggars belief.

I'm no extremist, but that's a good suggestion. Any ideas? Stay away as not on season ticket? leave at HT? Stand at bing gate instead?

She was as awful an interviewer as Caldwell is a manager. Woefully worded with a confrontational tone. Back to media school for her and back to management school for him.

I don't care about him either. Maybe it's Stockholm Syndrome?!? We are looking utterly doomed under him, and our only chance is to sack him. It's very grim just now.

As things remain we will definitely be relegated, so Caldwell needs to be sacked asap. I can't see any logical reasons for expecting am improvement in results under his management. As for the BBC interview, I felt the questions were quite annoying at times and many of the questions were basically repeats of previous ones using different words. She even asked at one point " is the referee the reason you lost?" I'd have been curt with her aswell if I was the manager, and inclined to highlight that we didn't lose. Though it did feel like a loss. Despite the hopeless results and likelihood of relegation, there is a slither of me that somehow feels sorry for Caldwell. It's entirely the fault of our board that we are in freefall and Caldwell (and the fans) should put out of our misery by sacking him. He's clearly out of his depth.

That's what we are all thinking! If Storey keeps playing I'd prefer he was in goals.

Storey has to be added to that list

So, lets say we sack Caldwell this week - what next??

To be clear, you want Caldwell sacked immediately on the basis of the last three matches?

Whilst a concerning start to his job, some of the condemnation aimed at a guy after just 3 games is embarrassing. He may well prove to be the wrong manager sooner or later, but isn't a bit of time the least a new manager should expect? If he is the wrong manager, the blame lies squarely with the board. The 18 month shambles prior to now can't be undone in 3 months never mind 3 weeks, although granted we did all expect some improved form which hasn't transpired. Its a difficult job for anyone to come in to, and at least 2 transfer windows are needed. What concerns me is it took 2.5 games to realise Mcginty is honking, but that can be couched by the fact we have zero defensive cover and maybe he was forced to give him a go. Why Sorey hasn't been banished from the squad completely is beyond me.

One transfer window won't be enough for Caldwell, he'll need the summer aswell to root out the deadwood. 30yrs, the worst defence I've seen. Cant win headers, weak in the tackle, poor distribution. Let's hope for 8th, and go again next season. Ps. Storey needs dropped to never return. He's so bad.

In context to the club's sole aim for the season and general rhetoric, the assembled squad somehow feels less than the sum of its parts. Disjointed by way of short term deals, loans, inexperience, fitness concerns and ability concerns. Imbalanced by way of heavy cover in some positions and limited cover in others. The squad still lacks a real spine and a real leader (we'll miss Tam O'ware) It's basically feels like we have a squad of past failures and unwanted dregs with little vested interest, all chucked together through necessity rather than choice/selection. It will be a minor miracle if we have a good season (reaching play offs imo). Cue Thistle 4-0 Morton!

Would you be interested in the managers job, should a vacancy arise?!!

Archie, Shaggy and all of the fitness/sports science team need to go. Whoever scouts, deals with and/or negotiates the players deals need to go too. Now is the time to act or this season could be worse than last.