Fan Ownership Working Group

[javeajag 833]

11 hours ago, Garscube Road End said:

With this mob there will be plenty to moan about after March.

Tbf you moan pretty much all the time ....no ?

[javeajag 833]

10 hours ago, Jordanhill Jag said:

Why is it Great News She is involved - did you think she was a Successful Chairman ? Just interested ? 

Not sure what her time as chairman has to do with the current situation......

[Garscube Road End 883]

11 minutes ago, javeajag said:

Tbf you moan pretty much all the time ....no ?

Only when you comment.

[Norgethistle 1,347]

1 hour ago, javeajag said:

Not sure what her time as chairman has to do with the current situation......

So why is it great she is involved?  What does she bring to the table?

I think it may be good Charan Gill is involved giving his business background, although a little surprised he got involved seeing as he effectively gave up his businesses and lavish lifestyle to live a no frills basic life, to concentrate on having fun, and got rid of all business interests. There’s an article where he basically states he drives a basic car and gets buy on £5 a day now, concentrating on his spiritual wellbeing rather than immaterial items.

His book is a very good read, for anyone interested 

[Semi Nurainen 316]

16 hours ago, javeajag said:

It’s great news she’s involved ....

after March you moan to yourself ,,,,, soo good ! 

I would say that anyone who wants somebody involved who has been so detrimental to the club (and some of its best servants) has absolutely no right to call themselves a Thistle Fan.

End of.

[BowenBoys 1,764]

1 hour ago, Semi Nurainen said:

I would say that anyone who wants somebody involved who has been so detrimental to the club (and some of its best servants) has absolutely no right to call themselves a Thistle Fan.

End of.

It's all about opinions and, I suspect, wind-ups. Or should that be winds-up?

[West of Scotland 195]

Anyone who finishes a post by using the phrase "end of" as though their opinion is some sort of fact has absolutely no right to call themselves anything other than a dick.

[Jordanhill Jag 312]

6 hours ago, javeajag said:

Not sure what her time as chairman has to do with the current situation......

Well its a gauge as to how you think she contributed to the Club - was it successful - did we move forward - were the Fans happy with her tenure - were we more stable financially - were we more successful on the Park - were Crowds Up - Matchday Experience Better 

You Know - all the things that you Measure a Chairman on - because Im assuming you think its Great she is involved based on her previous Track Record ? 

 

[javeajag 833]

38 minutes ago, Jordanhill Jag said:

Well its a gauge as to how you think she contributed to the Club - was it successful - did we move forward - were the Fans happy with her tenure - were we more stable financially - were we more successful on the Park - were Crowds Up - Matchday Experience Better 

You Know - all the things that you Measure a Chairman on - because Im assuming you think its Great she is involved based on her previous Track Record ? 

 

Have you met her ?

[javeajag 833]

3 hours ago, Semi Nurainen said:

I would say that anyone who wants somebody involved who has been so detrimental to the club (and some of its best servants) has absolutely no right to call themselves a Thistle Fan.

End of.

Just as well you don’t control who is a thistle fan as there would only be two ...you and you ....

[javeajag 833]

6 hours ago, Norgethistle said:

So why is it great she is involved?  What does she bring to the table?

I think it may be good Charan Gill is involved giving his business background, although a little surprised he got involved seeing as he effectively gave up his businesses and lavish lifestyle to live a no frills basic life, to concentrate on having fun, and got rid of all business interests. There’s an article where he basically states he drives a basic car and gets buy on £5 a day now, concentrating on his spiritual wellbeing rather than immaterial items.

His book is a very good read, for anyone interested 

She has a business background and knows the club and despite the bias of some men in here wants the club to do well 

[Garscube Road End 883]

13 minutes ago, javeajag said:

She has a business background and knows the club and despite the bias of some men in here wants the club to do well 

The bias of some men? Oh dear! You starting up the old misogyny crap?

[Garscube Road End 883]

14 minutes ago, javeajag said:

She has a business background and knows the club and despite the bias of some men in here wants the club to do well 

She is a disaster.

[Semi Nurainen 316]

52 minutes ago, Garscube Road End said:

The bias of some men? Oh dear! You starting up the old misogyny crap?

He's never stopped it. Desperate sycophant.

[Jordanhill Jag 312]

2 hours ago, javeajag said:

Have you met her ?

Yes - But why is that relevant ? 

[Jordanhill Jag 312]

2 hours ago, javeajag said:

She has a business background and knows the club and despite the bias of some men in here wants the club to do well 

Pretty sure we have a lot of Fans with Business Experience who know the Club - so based on her Track Record as Chairman your saying that she should return ? Just checking ?  

[Big Col 647]

2 hours ago, javeajag said:

She has a business background and knows the club and despite the bias of some men in here wants the club to do well 

She employed Caldwell and he has us in the position we are today. She threw her toys out the pram when criticised for the North Korean like videos. The fact that she’s a woman has nothing to do with it. Last line of defence for someone losing an argument - throw in an accusation of some kind of “ism”. Defend her for appointing Caldwell - I dare you.

[javeajag 833]

2 minutes ago, Jordanhill Jag said:

Yes - But why is that relevant ? 

Think about that 

[javeajag 833]

1 minute ago, Jordanhill Jag said:

Pretty sure we have a lot of Fans with Business Experience who know the Club - so based on her Track Record as Chairman your saying that she should return ? Just checking ?  

Stop .... you don’t like her ..., we know 

[javeajag 833]

10 minutes ago, Big Col said:

She employed Caldwell and he has us in the position we are today. She threw her toys out the pram when criticised for the North Korean like videos. The fact that she’s a woman has nothing to do with it. Last line of defence for someone losing an argument - throw in an accusation of some kind of “ism”. Defend her for appointing Caldwell - I dare you.

She didn’t appoint Caldwell the board did as required under company law....oh wait they were men so yes .....

[lady-isobel-barnett 3,629]

The appointment of Caldwell was of course a disaster but that in itself didn't make J Low  bad chairperson. Hundreds of chairmen have made disastrous mistakes re recruiting managers.

The lack of Club/Fan communication from a so called communication guru was deplorable. Also the way Doolan's exit was handled showed her up badly from a PR point of view. Those two issues were enough alone to welcome her departure. 

[Semi Nurainen 316]

15 minutes ago, javeajag said:

She didn’t appoint Caldwell the board did as required under company law....oh wait they were men so yes .....

This is the sort of clown who'll be running your club  show in a few months time. Read and weep.

Not even fit for a Bowling Club.

[javeajag 833]

5 minutes ago, Semi Nurainen said:

This is the sort of clown who'll be running your club  show in a few months time. Read and weep.

Not even fit for a Bowling Club.

You really have a thing against bowling clubs ... middle class snobbery 

[Big Col 647]

30 minutes ago, javeajag said:

She didn’t appoint Caldwell the board did as required under company law....oh wait they were men so yes .....

Let it go. She wasn’t removed because of her gender and you know it.

[sandy 807]

30 minutes ago, lady-isobel-barnett said:

The appointment of Caldwell was of course a disaster but that in itself didn't make J Low  bad chairperson. Hundreds of chairmen have made disastrous mistakes re recruiting managers.

The lack of Club/Fan communication from a so called communication guru was deplorable. Also the way Doolan's exit was handled showed her up badly from a PR point of view. Those two issues were enough alone to welcome her departure. 

This.